Skip to content
Business

Visa, Mastercard urge US judge to approve $38bn merchant settlement

Visa and Mastercard have urged a United States judge to approve their proposed $38bn settlement with merchants.

The case centres on allegations that the payment networks charged excessive fees for processing credit card transactions.

The two companies made the appeal on Monday during a court hearing in Brooklyn, New York, where US District Judge Brian Cogan considered the agreement.

The judge did not immediately decide whether to grant final approval. He warned that rejecting the settlement could lead to a “protracted process” if the 21-year-old case proceeded to trial.

The proposed agreement covers more than 12 million merchants and seeks to reduce the fees businesses pay to accept Visa and Mastercard payments. For the first time, it would also allow merchants to reject certain categories of cards instead of being compelled to accept all cards issued under either network.

Lawyers representing the payment companies described the deal as a fair compromise that would significantly change their longstanding relationships with merchants.

Visa’s lawyer, Michael Shuster, said the agreement offered “potent” relief to businesses. He added that the company was not “jumping with joy” over the proposed changes.

The settlement would cut swipe fees, also known as interchange fees, by 0.1 percentage point for five years.

It would also set an eight-year cap of 1.25 per cent on fees charged for standard consumer credit cards.

The agreement would additionally end the longstanding “Honor All Cards” rule, which requires merchants to accept all Visa or Mastercard cards if they accept any of them.

Under the proposed changes, businesses would be able to choose whether to accept commercial cards, premium consumer cards (including rewards cards), or standard consumer cards.

The proposal has, however, drawn opposition from several major retailers and industry groups, including Walmart and the National Retail Federation.

More than 1,000 objections were submitted to the court. Critics argued that the settlement would not reduce fees enough or introduce meaningful competition among card issuers.

Mithun Mansinghani, a lawyer representing the National Association of Convenience Stores and Circle K, which opposed the agreement, argued that the proposal lacked structural reforms that would encourage competition among banks and other card issuers.

He also maintained that fees on commercial and premium consumer cards, which account for more than 90 per cent of the card market, would remain excessively high.

“Competition should be the North Star … and this settlement is way off course,” he said. “It’s like building a bridge that goes a quarter of the way across the Hudson [River]. It doesn’t work.”

Despite the opposition, supporters of the agreement, including the Electronic Payments Coalition, argued that it would provide substantial relief to merchants.

Two experts engaged by the plaintiffs, Nobel Prize-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz and University of Washington professor Keith Leffler, estimated that the changes could save businesses $38bn by 2031. They said the changes could also generate $224bn in overall benefits, including for consumers.

The dispute dates back more than two decades. Merchants have accused Visa, Mastercard and banks of conspiring to violate US antitrust laws through excessive swipe fees.

According to the Merchants Payments Coalition, Visa and Mastercard collected $118.8bn in swipe fees in the United States in 2025. That compares with $111.2bn in 2024 and $25.6bn in 2009.

The average fee stood at 2.36 per cent.

Cogan granted the settlement preliminary approval in June. A previous $30bn agreement was rejected by another judge in June 2024, who considered it insufficient.

American Express and Capital One’s Discover network are not parties to the proposed settlement.

Share

Top News