Skip to content
Conferences

COP31 risks collapse as EU rejects latest climate deal

The chances of the world securing a deal at COP31 are diminishing “by the hour”, Ireland’s Climate and Energy Minister Darragh O’Brien said on Sunday.

The United Nations climate talks in Antalya, Turkey, have been pushed deep into overtime.

O’Brien, whose country holds the rotating EU presidency, said a proposed agreement “lacks the climate ambition that is needed to tackle this climate crisis. We’re very disappointed by that”.

A new draft deal was released two days after the conference was scheduled to end, but it has yet to be approved. Australia, supported by Turkiye, has been tasked with finding a deal that balances the needs of nations most vulnerable to climate change against those whose economies depend on producing or consuming fossil fuels.

The latest offering from the co-hosts, Turkey and Australia, was published deep into overtime and again fails to mention fossil fuels.

It needs consensus approval from nearly 200 nations at a closing session.

A draft unveiled earlier in the week called for a faster phase-out of fossil fuels. A pared-down version released on Thursday removed all mentions of coal, oil and gas.

The latest text refers to a 2023 global deal to shift the world away from fossil fuels, but stops short of naming them.

The European Union and other nations have pushed for strong language on transitioning away from fossil fuels, a call that has met resistance from oil-rich Saudi Arabia. A Saudi official declined to comment when approached by AFP.

O’Brien also told reporters in Antalya on Sunday that the EU would not support a final declaration that does not even mention fossil fuels.

Germany and France have also rejected the draft agreement.

An EU official told AFP the latest proposal was a step backwards. The official warned of a “very real possibility” that COP31 would end with no deal, and said they were more pessimistic than the day before.

A German official described the situation as difficult and the outcome as uncertain, saying oil-producing countries were putting up a fierce fight.

Threats of a walkout prompted Turkey and Australia to convene a hurried meeting between the EU and Saudi Arabia, the opposing camps on fossil fuels, in a bid to broker a compromise.

Antigua and Barbuda’s environment minister, Michael Joseph, said he was very disappointed with the text. He said he could not say he was comfortable with it passing in its current state, describing it as largely silent on fossil fuels.

The draft calls for global efforts to raise electricity’s share of total final energy consumption to 35 per cent by 2035, and to expand “clean energy”.

Some nations had demanded an explicitly clean target, to ensure the electrification push is powered by renewables rather than fossil fuels. Around one-third of global electricity is produced using coal and another fifth using fossil gas.

The text also retains a contentious push to expand carbon capture and storage, a technology championed by the fossil fuel industry but criticised as costly and ineffective in cutting emissions. Environmental group 350.org said it was disappointed by the omission of fossil fuels and by the draft’s encouragement of carbon-removal technologies.

Another source of friction has been attempts by Saudi Arabia, India and Kenya to delay the next set of reports by the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Dozens of countries across Europe, Africa and the Pacific want them published in time for a crucial stocktake of global carbon-cutting efforts in 2028. The draft text “highlights the importance” of the reports.

Countries have also disagreed over how to respond to the looming breach of the 1.5C warming target set under the Paris climate accord. The latest draft expresses “deep concern” that global warming will cross 1.5C above pre-industrial levels in the next few years.

The talks have also jammed over long-running complaints that rich nations are shirking their obligations to help developing countries confront climate change. The removal of a $120 billion target for climate adaptation angered developing nations.

The summit comes against a difficult backdrop of soaring energy prices and geopolitical tensions stemming from the war in Iran. It also comes in a year of climate-linked disasters from Europe to Nepal and Indonesia.

Share

Top News