Members of the House of Representatives were split on Wednesday over a motion seeking the cancellation of outstanding loans that farmers obtained under various government-backed agricultural intervention programmes.
Lawmakers could not agree on whether distressed farmers should be given debt relief or made to undergo an investigation.
The motion was sponsored by Inuwa Garba, who represents the Yamaltu/Deba federal constituency of Gombe State.
It was based on the economic hardship facing farmers, especially the effects of insecurity, climate change, natural disasters and other challenges that have disrupted agricultural production across the country.
In recent years, the federal government introduced several agricultural financing initiatives, among them the Anchor Borrowers’ Programme, the Commercial Agriculture Credit Scheme and NIRSAL-supported facilities. They were meant to boost food production, empower farmers and strengthen national food security.
Leading the debate, Garba said insecurity, banditry, insurgency, farmer-herder clashes, flooding, drought and other environmental challenges had seriously undermined farming activities. According to him, these problems caused crop failures, loss of investments and reduced farm incomes.
He argued that many beneficiaries of the government-sponsored loans could not meet their repayment obligations. In his view, this was not because they were unwilling to pay, but because circumstances beyond their control had badly affected their productive capacity and financial stability.
Garba further said that continued accumulation and enforcement of the outstanding debts, including principal, interest and penalties, could push struggling farmers deeper into poverty. He added that it could expose them to asset seizures and discourage them from taking part in future agricultural activities.
Opposing the proposed debt cancellation, Bamidele Salam, who represents the Ede South/Ede North/Ejigbo/Egbedore federal constituency of Osun State, questioned the justification for a blanket waiver. He cited findings in the Auditor-General for the Federation’s report before the House.
Salam, who chairs the House Committee on Public Accounts, alleged that some beneficiaries of agricultural intervention loans amounting to over ₦1tn diverted the funds into businesses and personal investments.
He alleged that some of those who approached the Central Bank of Nigeria and commercial banks for agricultural loans channelled the money into real estate in Abuja, Lagos and even Dubai.
The lawmaker also raised concern about the Bank of Agriculture, which he said had been left almost immobile by ₦795billion in loans owed by beneficiaries, many of whom allegedly diverted the funds.
Salam warned that approving a blanket waiver without first establishing how the loans were used would set a dangerous precedent for future government intervention programmes.
He said: “If we come as a parliament and recommend a holistic waiving of all loans given out to persons who are purportedly to be farmers, we will be setting a very, very dangerous precedent for people to come, access government facilities, some of them interest-free, some of them single-digit interest, only for them to go and use those monies for other things.”
Isiaka Ibrahim, a lawmaker from Ogun State, supported Salam’s position. He alleged that some people took government loans only to spend the funds on personal pursuits, including marrying additional wives.
Ibrahim, however, admitted that a thorough investigation could identify genuine farmers whose businesses had been hit by economic hardship and who were therefore unable to repay their loans.
Paul Kalejaiye, an All Progressives Congress lawmaker from Lagos State, also urged the House to be cautious. He stressed the need to investigate how funds disbursed under the various agricultural intervention schemes were used before any decision on debt forgiveness is taken.
Following the disagreement and the lawmakers’ failure to reach a consensus, the House adjourned further consideration of the motion until Tuesday, November 24, for additional legislative scrutiny.